Whats this you say? Youre electrically charging thin diaphragms
millimeters from my ears? I thought we were going to review headphones,
not conduct an experiment with Dr. Frankenstein!
Well, for those of you new to the audiophile world, there are other ways
to produce sounds than the standard
round
cones like you see in most speakers, (FYI - standard headphones are called
Dynamic headphones). One of those other technologies is whats
called Electrostatic. There are several high end companies producing
very highly regarded electrostatic speakers, and there are lots of
audiophiles who swear by these flat, different looking speakers.
Electrostatic speaker technology, though lacking on bass, is best
known for its incredible detail and ability to sonically
disappear, (i.e. difficult to pinpoint exactly where the sound is
coming from). Not being an electrical engineer and barely understanding the
technology myself, I am not going to go into an explanation of how electrostatic
speakers work. But lets just say in the audiophile headphone world,
electrostatic headphones are also highly regarded!
Not headphones...Earspeakers? That what Stax likes to call them! Stax, a
Japan based company, has been producing electrostatic earspeakers since the
late 50s or early 60s. Surprise, this is not a new technology!
Its just more expensive to produce than a standard dynamic headphone,
so electrostatic headphones are not a mass merchandised product. A few other
companies produce an electrostatic headphone or two, but Stax is
known as the main player in this arena.
Being a headphone enthusiast, a couple of years ago, I was so curious to
hear some electrostatic headphones, that I bought a pair of used Stax earspeakers
through an auction on E-Bay for a little over $100. First off, electrostatic
earspeakers do not plug into a standard headphone jack. When my used Stax
SR40s were made, (I am guessing mid 80s?), you had to connect a black
box to the speaker outputs of an amplifier in order to power them. Lets
just say, while the used earspeakers seemed to work just fine, sound quality
wise, they didnt even compare to a Grado SR60 which can be had for
$69. Due to the smaller size of my used Stax, I am guessing they were a lesser
expensive model to begin with. Live and Learn?
Then, quite by accident, in January, while attending the huge Consumer
Electronics Show, I stumbled upon the Stax booth. I listened to several of
their models of electrostatic earspeakers, and was quite impressed! So much
so, I went back a second time to listen a little closer and determine if
I should spend some quality time back at review central comparing them with
my almighty Grado RS1s?
The Rest of the Story: Well here it is, a few months later, GoodCans.com
is now an official Stax dealer, and I am currently listening to the Stax
SRS-2020 earspeakers! At $825, the 2020s are the entry level model
which
Stax dubs Basic System II. Stax
earspeakers still cannot be plugged directly into a headphone jack, but they
are more user friendly now in that they come with their own headphone amp
which can be plugged directly into a source with standard stereo RCA jacks,
(like a CD player, Pre-amp or Receiver Tape output, or a headphone output
with an appropriate connector cord). Yes, you read that right, the
headphone amp is included! So even though the 2020 is a bit more
expensive than the $700 top of the line Grado RS1, the price is more equivalent
to the combination of the $495 Grado RS2 headphones with the $350 Grado RA1
headphone amp.
The headphone amp supplied with the Stax SRS-2020 combination is a smallish
black box, approximately 5(w) x 2(h) x 6 (d). Powered by
a standard wall wart, (AC adapter), this headphone setup is not totally portable.
The ribbon like cord on the headphones is a little over 7 feet long, seems
to be of good quality and plugs into the amp with a five prong connection.
The headphones themselves, oh, excuse me, earspeakers, are fairly large
rectangular ribbed boxes. These are definitely of the open design, sounds
around you can be heard and those around you can hear your music. Though
large, they are light in weight, and comfortable due to the circumaural,
(around the ear rather than on the ear), design. Earpads are leather, a nice
long lasting touch, but can be a bit warm on the ear after listening a while.
The headband is of the two part design. The top piece is plastic while the
bottom adjustable band is leather. I have a smallish head and the earspeakers
fit on my head just fine on the smallest adjustment. But a smaller child
would not be able to comfortably wear these full size headphones. FYI, other
than the leather, most of the outside of the earspeakers is made of plastic.
Another reason I might not want to travel with these headphones. I am pretty
careful with my equipment, so I would expect the Staxs to last me many
years. But those of you who are hard on things, beware, these things could
be broken with abuse.
The all important How Do They Sound: In a word,
Nice! I like acoustical music. Not a lot going on. In other words, when listening
closely to my music, I want to be able to hear the individual instruments.
This is where the Stax SRS-2020 earspeaker system shines! The detail is on
par with my familiar Grado headphones, yet allows more space to be heard
around the instruments due to its large, very open design. More depth
in the music. They seem to tackle a problem I have had in listening to
Sennheisers best dynamic headphones. While the Sennheiser HD590s and
HD600s offer more space around the instruments than do the Grados, the
Senns just sound muffled in comparison to the incredible detail the
Grados have to offer. For the type of music I listen to, the Stax SRS-2020
earspeaker system is a winner!
But now the nit-picking. Notice I was careful to mention the type of music
I like to listen to in my personal listening sessions. While the bass on
these electrostatic headphones seems fine to my ears, they do seem to lack
Slam. There is not a lot of punch to the sound and if your primary
musical interest is the more popular Pop/Rock, etc., you probably would be
better off with a pair of Grados! Adjusting the volume control on the
Stax amp to almost full volume does not compensate for the lack of
Slam either. In fact, connecting the Stax system to my portable
CD player just barely passes the listenable volume level, (almost a strike
three against using the Stax as a transportable listening system). Given
that the majority of music listeners prefer mostly upbeat, a lot going on,
type of music, a Grado headphone purchase would probably be the smarter move.
One exception though. A well recorded full size orchestra, even though there
are lots of instruments, sounds fuller to me with the Stax earspeakers.
Conclusions: The average listener would probably
prefer the excellent, all around high quality headphones Grado has to offer.
The Grados offer incredible detail for dynamic headphones, and in the
words of many a listener, They Rock! Plus, the entire line of
Grado headphones seem to me that they would be more durable given the abuse
so many people give to items that get handled a lot. However, if your primary
musical preferences are Classical, Jazz, Acoustical Folk, Bluegrass, or well
recorded vocal; you should definitely consider some Stax Electrostatic
Earspeakers! To me they add an extra dimension to the music that the Grado's
don't quite match up to!
Copyright © 2001 Bill Keyser and Listening Station, All Rights Reserved |