(Update:)
xDream Wireless Cans
now $120! Click For Details
Sometime in December, (2000), I received an E-mail from Mr. Neoh Chong Lim
inviting me to visit his booth at CES in January. He had read some of my
articles on headphones posted on the Internet at www.GoodCans.com and was
particularly interested in my negative comments concerning wireless headphones.
You see, his company, FreeSystems Pte Ltd., has a new trade marked
technology called Freespan. He thought I might be impressed
with his new wireless, infrared, digital transmission headphones with the
trademarked name, xdream. Though not a regular CES attendee in
the past, I just happened to be preparing to take in the show this year.
Anyway, I visited his booth, tried out some of their xdream headphones, sat
in a seat and listened to wireless surround sound speakers, and spoke briefly
to Mr. Neoh. My first impressions were favorable, but as you might guess,
judging a product from such a brief encounter in a noisy environment is not
really very telling. Thankfully, Mr. Neoh again contacted me by E-mail after
the show and offered to send a pair of xdream headphones for me to personally
review in the comfort of my own listening environment. The following are
my thoughts and comments on this new product and technology:
The first thing noticeably different about the xdream wireless
Cans is the red oval mound placed on top. It looks like a product
drawn for the Jetsons cartoon... you know, the 21st century
family that travels in flying cars and lives in high rise buildings that
look like flying saucers! Well, anyway, the red bubble is obviously the receiving
unit, which I am assuming is a necessary evil required to receive the best
infrared signal possible. And the transmission unit, it looks like a little
toy version of a space ship from Star Trek! Youre going to have to
work hard to convince the kids that these arent toys, but rather, a
serious wireless listening setup!
The transmission unit set up is rather normal for a wireless
transmitter. A left and right input using standard RCA jacks. You need to
connect to an audio out or use a Y-connector to plug into a standard mini
headphone jack. BTW, I think most of the cords for connection are included,
even a USB cord. Whats this? A USB connection! FreeSystems must be
planning on marketing this product towards computer users and gamers in addition
to music listeners and home theater (Note: since this is a computer thing,
USB connection is not supported by the folks at Listening Station
Headphones). In fact, there is a switch on the transmission unit
for switching between close and further away positions, (I guess sitting
at a computer with the headphones on, 2 or 3 feet away from the transmission
unit requires a bit different signal output?). Not having a high quality
sound card in my self assembled computer, I bypassed testing the xdream with
my computer for now. Just to note that some of the simplest tasks, dont
always get done right: The xdream review unit I received was easy to connect,
and seemed to work fine without a hitch. Then, when comparing the sound to
some other headphones, I noticed a problem. The left and the right channels
were switched? I double checked my connections, and all seemed correct? After
some thought, I just switched the left and the right RCA connections, and
all seemed to be fine at this point. Upon later contact with Mr. Neoh, he
assured me that my test unit was a pre-production model and that the problem
shouldnt exist in the final product. (Note: left/right problem was
corrected)
OK, lets get to the sound! Can wireless Cans even come close
to comparing to the sound quality of a wired headphone? Up until
I listened to the xdream, my answer to this question was a resounding
NO! But wait, this headphone is sounding pretty darn good! Could
it be that a wire strung across the room in order to have good sound quality
is no longer needed? Yes, this Freespan technology does
have some real potential. I am moving freely about the room, receiving
a super clear signal... I am even dancing with these headphones on! Oops,
when I ducked my head, and my body came in between the transmitter and the
receiver, I lost the signal. Unlike RF, (radio frequency), wireless technology
where reception can even go through walls, Infrared needs a clear line of
sight and is limited to about 20 feet from the source. But in Freespans
favor, RF reception does not even come close to sounding this
good!
Now about the headphones: Havent I seen these before? Yes, I did a
review of some RF wireless Advent headphones about a year ago and the Cans
looked exactly the same! Full sized, circumaural, Closed
headphones. Soft velvety type earpad material. Quite comfy. But
frankly, I wasnt too impressed with the sound quality of the Advent.
They were bass heavy and muddy. Well, in the world of electronics, a company
cant build everything from scratch. I am assuming FreeSystems has sourced
the generic headphone housing from a third party and adapted their Freespan
technology into it? And judging by the sound, possibly the transducers are
different than those Advents because this sound is clearly superior!
What's Included: The xdream headphones come with the infra-red
transmitter, the AC/DC adapter to power the transmitter, the headphones with
the built in IR receiver and amp, a USB cable, a Y-cord interconnect
(mini-headphone plug to two RCA's) to connect the transmitter to a headphone
output, a 1/4" to 1/8" adapter to plug the previous cord into a standard
size headphone output, two rechargeable batteries for the headphone unit,
a cord to plug the headphones into the transmitter while recharging the
batteries, and the instruction manual. Basically, it comes with
everything you need to connect the xdream up as long as you connect to a
headphone output or a computer with USB ports. In a few cases, some
of you may need to supply a standard RCA to RCA interconnect to plug into
a standard line level output on a TV, receiver or pre-amp. My HDTV doesn't
have a headphone output so this is how I first connected to my TV, (if you
are like me, I have about a dozen of these inexpensive cords lying in drawers
all around the house).
Sound Quality: Can wireless headphones excite this headphone
reviewers ears... in a word... YES! Detail is quite good,
both in the mids and the highs. And even the bass is sounding pretty darn
good. Could these compete with my almighty Grados... er, well, no.
You see, the xdream is a Closed headphone. If you have read any
of the information at www.GoodCans.com, you may know that Closed
headphones usually dont quite sound as natural as do Open
headphones. This is a known phenomenon that I believe was widely marketed
by Sennheiser even back in the 70s? But I believe there is a reason
the xdream is closed. In order to receive the wireless signal and control
volume, a little headphone amp is built into the headphone. In addition,
two AAA batteries are also placed inside the headphone to power the amp and
the wireless receiver, plus there is a volume control and an on/off button.
In other words, an Open headphone would be kind of difficult
given all that is required to be built into the headphone housing. BTW, you
may be thinking, These must be pretty heavy headphones? Well,
actually, they are not all that heavy. I remember a lot of huge Cans from
the 60s and 70s that weighed more than these things! Additional
comfort note: I have listened to over 50 headphones in the past two years,
and believe me, these are actually pretty comfortable headphones due to the
soft earpad material and the fit around the ears!
OK, so they sound good, but not as good as Open Grados.
What do they compare to? Well, I am currently reviewing
four "Wired," Closed Sennheisers ranging in price from $100 to
$200. The wireless xdream Cans so compare quite favorably. They easily outclass
the circumaural Senn HD270. The supra-aural Senn HD25-sp1 seems to match
the xdream in detail, but the circumaural design of the xdream gives it a
larger sound space resulting in my ears preferring the xdream for both sound
quality and comfort. Its not until I get up to the $200 Senn Cans that
the xdream doesnt quite match up in sound quality. But its darn
close! I had to listen very closely to determine as such and my critical
listening for reviews is more discriminating than would be required by the
average listener. And remember, all of the above headphones I am
comparing the xdreams to are Wired Cans! To further
tout the quality of the Freespan technology, I did have the opportunity to
compare the xdream with a $200 RF wireless Senn SR60. Frankly, there was
no comparison! Though the $200 wireless Senn is better than the $100 wireless
Cans I reviewed last year, the xdream is in a class above them. While
I wouldnt even consider comparing any of the wireless Senns with a
wired headphone, the xdream is most definitely comparable to a "wired" headphone!
This wireless technology is the real thing! While the sound
quality of the xdream rivals very competitively with some very good
Closed headphones, if you mated the Freespan technology with
some Grados, you would have some very serious Wireless
headphones indeed! And guess what! FreeSystems is working on a project with
Grado. Though it sounds like it is going to be quite spendy, it looks like
they are going to mate the wireless receiver to a special edition Grado headphone
amp and include a special edition headphone that looks an awful lot like
a Grado SR325! As someone very familiar with Grado products, I know Grado
wouldnt mess with the technology if it didnt offer sound quality
rivaling corded sound!
Personally, at first I didnt see the point of wireless headphones that
require staying in the same room as the source. After all, a cheap headphone
extension cord can be purchased for $10 and a good one for $40! But I have
had the xdream connected to my home theater setup for a while now, and I
am beginning to realize why some people would want wireless. Being able to
pick up the headphones at any time without unraveling the extension cord
for use and then having to put it away; not having a cord running across
my family room floor makes for a straightened room; and the no tripping
factor.
Please Note: About the only problems we've even encountered with reception
quality had to do with very bright sunlight or plasma TV's. Please don't
purchase the xDream if you're primary area of use is in front of a Plasma
TV.
Potential Uses: The xdream wireless headphone works quite
nicely for home theater watching. I know my family room already has enough
cords strung about... now when will I get to use this technology with my
surround sound speakers! And the USB connection makes it a natural with computer
gaming or music files. In fact, I could see a student in a dorm room using
the xdream to listen to mp3 files across the room from their computer. And
yes, even a person looking for the best sounding wireless headphones for
use with their music audio system will have to consider the xdreams! Just
remember though... these are IR and you have to stay in the same room as
the transmitter.
I dont know if FreeSystems plans on tweaking the xdream in
the near future, but for a first outing, they have created a very good sounding
wireless headphone that demands attention! In other words, if you like the
idea of corded sound quality from Wireless Cans, the xdream is
a Dream Come True!
Copyright © 2001-2006, 2008 Bill Keyser and Listening Station, All Rights
Reserved |